We all know the importance of hiring the right people for our organization. The right hire can bring in fresh perspectives, new ideas, and valuable skills that contribute to the growth and success of a company. On the other hand, the wrong hire can result in lost time, resources, and productivity.
So, how can we ensure that we are making the right hiring decisions and bringing in top-quality talent? This is where Quality of Hire (QoH) comes into play.
Unlike basic metrics like time-to-fill or cost-per-hire, QoH evaluates how well new employees contribute to the company over time. It provides insight into whether your hiring process brings high-performing, engaged employees who drive success – or if adjustments are needed.
In this guide, I’ll explain how to measure Quality of Hire, why it matters, and how to refine your hiring strategies to get better results.
What is Quality of Hire (QoH)?
Quality of Hire is a data-driven metric that evaluates how effective and valuable a new employee is to the organization. Instead of focusing on just hiring efficiency, it assesses whether the person hired was actually a good fit – both in terms of skills and cultural alignment.
Companies that measure QoH can identify what’s working in their hiring process and where improvements are needed. It helps answer key questions like:
- Are new hires performing at or above expectations?
- Do they stay with the company long-term?
- Are they engaged and aligned with company goals?
Without tracking this metric, hiring decisions can feel like guesswork. However, with a clear understanding of QoH, companies can make more informed, strategic hiring choices.
How to Measure Quality of Hire
There’s no single formula for measuring QoH – it varies by company and industry. However, the most effective approach is to use a combination of performance data, retention rates, and feedback from employees and managers.
Here are some of the most commonly used metrics:
1. Employee Performance Ratings
One of the most direct ways to measure QoH is by evaluating an employee’s performance over time. This can include:
- Manager evaluations: Does the employee meet or exceed expectations?
- Key performance indicators (KPIs): Are they hitting their goals?
- Productivity levels: How does their output compare to similar employees?
Tracking performance data in the first 6-12 months can reveal whether a hire is truly successful or if adjustments are needed in the hiring process.
2. Retention and Turnover Rates
A high turnover rate among new hires is a red flag. If employees leave within their first year, it’s a sign that something in the hiring process isn’t working – whether it’s mismatched expectations, poor cultural fit, or a lack of career growth opportunities.
To measure QoH through retention:
- Track how many new hires stay beyond the first year.
- Compare retention rates between different hiring sources (recruiters, job boards, referrals).
- Analyze exit interview data to understand why employees leave.
Retention is one of the most important indicators of Quality of Hire because engaged, satisfied employees stay and contribute longer.
3. Time to Productivity
A great hire doesn’t just stay – they ramp up quickly and start making an impact. Time to productivity measures how long it takes a new employee to reach full effectiveness in their role.
This can be tracked through:
- Training completion times.
- Speed of contribution to projects.
- Feedback from team members and managers.
If new hires consistently struggle to become productive, it could indicate gaps in onboarding, training, or hiring criteria.
4. Employee Engagement & Satisfaction
In addition to performance, Quality of Hire is also about engagement. Employees who are engaged are more likely to be motivated, productive, and committed to the company long-term.
Ways to measure engagement include:
- New hire surveys (e.g., “How satisfied are you in your role?”)
- Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS)
- Participation in company initiatives and culture-building activities.
If new employees aren’t engaged, it could signal issues with the work environment, leadership, or job expectations.
5. Hiring Manager Satisfaction
Hiring managers work directly with new employees, so their feedback is crucial in assessing hiring success. Companies can gather insights by asking managers:
- Did the new hire meet your expectations?
- How would you rate their contribution so far?
- Would you rehire this person?
If hiring managers frequently express disappointment with new hires, it’s a sign that the hiring process may need adjustments.
How to Improve Quality of Hire
If your QoH metrics reveal gaps or inconsistencies, the good news is that there are clear ways to refine your hiring strategy.
1. Define Success Clearly
Before making a new hire, ensure there’s a clear definition of what success looks like for the role. This means:
- Outlining key skills and behaviors needed for the position.
- Setting measurable goals for the first 30, 60, and 90 days.
- Aligning expectations between recruiters, hiring managers, and executives.
When success is well-defined upfront, it’s easier to measure and achieve.
2. Use Structured Interviews
Unstructured interviews can lead to biased and inconsistent hiring decisions. Instead, using a structured approach ensures:
- All candidates are evaluated on the same criteria.
- Hiring decisions are based on data, not just gut feelings.
- Interviewers focus on job-relevant skills rather than personal impressions.
Incorporating behavioral and situational questions can also help predict future performance more accurately.
3. Strengthen Onboarding
A well-structured onboarding process can significantly improve new hire success and retention. Make sure your onboarding includes:
- A clear roadmap for learning and growth.
- Regular check-ins with managers and mentors.
- Opportunities for early wins to boost confidence and engagement.
When employees feel supported from day one, they’re more likely to succeed and stay long-term.
4. Continuously Collect and Analyze Data
Improving QoH is an ongoing process. Regularly analyzing hiring data allows companies to:
- Identify patterns in high-performing employees.
- Adjust job descriptions to attract better-suited candidates.
- Improve recruitment channels based on success rates.
Companies that treat hiring as a data-driven process will see continuous improvements in QoH over time.
Final Thoughts
While it might seem challenging to measure and improve Quality of Hire at first, focusing on the right metrics and making data-driven hiring decisions can make a significant impact.
I hope this provided some good food for thought. If you’re looking to refine your hiring strategy or need help finding top talent for your organization, feel free to reach out to the Insight Recruitment team or send me a message here on LinkedIn.
And if you haven’t already, make sure to subscribe to my newsletter to get notified about upcoming editions!
